# Beauty Validation Report

**Date:** 2026-07-26  
**Validator:** Automated + self-audit

---

## Quality Gates

| Gate | Command / Method | Result | Notes |
|------|------------------|--------|-------|
| Type check (beauty scope) | `read_lints modules/beauty` | ✅ Pass | Zero diagnostics |
| ESLint (beauty scope) | IDE lints on `modules/beauty` | ✅ Pass | |
| Route architecture | `npm run validate:beauty-routes` | ✅ Pass | 98 pages, 8 layouts, thin adapters |
| Import boundaries | `npm run validate:beauty-imports` | ✅ Pass | No cross-module imports |
| Module location | Manual audit | ✅ Pass | Business code in `modules/beauty` only |
| App directory | Manual audit | ✅ Pass | Routes re-export from modules |
| Mock data | Grep audit | ✅ Pass | No mock fixtures in beauty module |
| API connection | Resource config audit | ✅ Pass | All buttons wired to `beautyBusinessApi` |

---

## Build & Typecheck (Monolith)

| Check | Result | Notes |
|-------|--------|-------|
| `npm run typecheck` | ⚠ Partial | Pre-existing errors in `hospitality`, `healthcare/admin`, `accounting` — **zero beauty errors** |
| `npm run build` | ⚠ Blocked | Fails on `hospitality/HospitalityListCrudPage.tsx` missing `z` import — unrelated to beauty |
| Beauty compile | ✅ | Next.js compiled successfully before type gate failed on other module |

---

## CRUD Validation (Owner Entities)

| Entity | Create tested via config | List | Update | Delete | Workflow |
|--------|--------------------------|------|--------|--------|----------|
| organizations | ✅ API method | ✅ | ✅ API | ✅ API | — |
| branches | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | — |
| appointments | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | — | ✅ 5 actions |
| All other entities | ✅ createFn | ✅ listFn | N/A (no API) | N/A (no API) | — |

---

## Permission Validation

- `useBeautyPermissions` gates workspace view/manage
- Tenant owner + platform admin → full manage
- `.view` permissions allow read for authenticated tenant members
- `PermissionDeniedState` shown when view denied
- Settings + admin permissions page read `permissions/catalog`

---

## Responsive Validation

- Workspace: `sm:grid-cols-2` forms, card grid `sm:grid-cols-2 xl:grid-cols-3`
- TableToolbar wraps on mobile
- Detail drawer `side="left"` RTL-friendly
- Portal shells use existing responsive nav

---

## Accessibility Validation

- Action buttons have `aria-label` (view/edit/delete icons)
- Timeline uses semantic `<ol>` + `<time datetime>`
- Form fields labeled
- Confirm dialogs for destructive/workflow actions

---

## Performance Validation

- TanStack Query with `staleTime` on permissions catalog (5 min)
- Debounced search (300ms via `useDebouncedValue`)
- Lookup queries shared via `useBeautyLookups`
- No N+1 in new components (list + optional audit on detail open only)

---

## Design System Validation

- Uses `@/components/ds` primitives
- `BeautyStatusChip`, tokens from `modules/beauty/design-system`
- CSS variables: `--beauty-*`, `--surface`, `--border`, `--muted`
- Consistent with healthcare `ResourceWorkspace` pattern

---

## Self-Audit Findings & Repairs

| Issue | Resolution |
|-------|------------|
| Owner pages partial CRUD | Replaced with `BeautyResourceWorkspace` |
| Reception check-in disconnected | Added `ReceptionAppointmentRow` with real mutations |
| Admin lists basic | Switched to read-only workspace |
| Settings no edit | Added upsert edit flow |
| Integrations read-only | Added create + tabs per integration type |
| Missing permission hook | Added `useBeautyPermissions` |
| Broken admin.tsx after edit | Removed orphaned JSX |

---

## Remaining Items (Out of Frontend Scope)

1. Backend PATCH/delete routes for secondary entities — enables full CRUD in UI
2. Monolith build fix for hospitality module
3. Customer reviews/messages — require CRM/Communication APIs
4. `validate:beauty-bundle` — run after monolith build succeeds

---

## Sign-Off

Beauty frontend module meets production-ready criteria for **all API-supported operations** across 98 routes. Full monolith build blocked by unrelated hospitality TypeScript error; beauty-specific validations all pass.
