# Product Integration — Audit & Scope Lock

> Milestone: Product Completion / UX Completion / Enterprise Integration  
> Date: 2026-07-27  
> Source of truth: `docs/project-status.yaml`  
> Constraint: **No new business services. No future roadmap phases** (QR, Short Link, Booking, Clinic foundation, Payment 14.6+, Experience FE-11.6 registry engines).

## In-scope services (IN_PROGRESS or COMPLETE + frontend incomplete)

| Service | Backend | Frontend | Integration focus |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Identity | complete | partial | polish only |
| Accounting | in_progress (5.11) | partial | API consumers only |
| CRM | complete | partial | polish |
| Loyalty | in_progress (7.6) | **exists** (status stale at 0%) | connect to flows |
| Communication | complete | in_progress | SMS MVP usable |
| Sports Center | in_progress (9.7) | partial/hub | no 9.8+ |
| Delivery | in_progress (10.8) | in_progress | no 10.9+ |
| Experience | complete | complete (FE-11.5) | scaffold→real CRUD; stop before FE-11.6 |
| Hospitality | in_progress (12.8) | hub exists | no 12.9+ |
| Healthcare | complete | partial | polish |
| Beauty | complete | partial | polish |
| Payment | MVP 14.5 + FE complete | complete | no 14.6+ |

## Out of scope (future / planned)

Ecommerce, Marketplace, Clinic foundation, Hotel, Tourism, Link Shortener, QR, Digital Card, Booking, Notification foundation, Payment refunds/splits (14.6+), Experience Publish Registry FE-11.6+.

## Part 1 — Frontend audit (summary)

| Area | Finding | Action |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Experience list CRUD | Many scaffold `code/name/status` forms mismatched API | Patched workspace-bound creates; child lists → `readOnly` |
| Experience site-domains | Required `site_id` caused `[object Object]` | Fixed filters + error formatting |
| Home `torbatyar.ir` | App launcher only | Transformed to Business Onboarding assessment |
| Onboarding | Free-text business type | Intent select + recommended bundle preview |
| Loyalty FE status | project-status `frontend_percent: 0` stale | Corrected in status update |
| Hospitality/Delivery FE | Hubs exist; depth varies | Documented; no new phase APIs |
| Fake charts | Payment/Experience dashboards use live counts | Keep; no mock KPI invention |

## Part 2 — Cross-service integration (existing APIs)

| Link | Contract basis | Status |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Vertical → Payment | ADR-020/021 publish_id / payment intent refs | MVP APIs live; vertical connectors deferred (14.8) |
| Payment → Accounting | Settlement intents / no shared DB | Ledger in Payment; Accounting posting via provider pattern |
| Payment → Communication | Receipt SMS via Communication | Deferred until consumer wiring phase |
| Experience publish → others | ADR-022 `publish_id` | **Architecture only** until FE-11.6 / registry phase |
| Delivery → Accounting | Settlement refs | Implemented in Delivery 10.8 |
| Tenant isolation | ADR-003 | Enforced per service middleware |
| Bundle / feature toggles | ADR-017/021 three-layer | Per-service bundles exist; commercial catalog is FE recommendation layer |

## Part 3 — E2E business flows

| Flow | Executable today? | Gap |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Restaurant full (menu→publish→pay→dispatch→loyalty→SMS→accounting) | **Partial** | Publish registry, vertical payment connector, SMS trigger wiring incomplete |
| Doctor/clinic full | **Partial** | Clinic foundation + Booking future; Healthcare hub usable |
| Retail full (QR/short link) | **Blocked** | QR + Short Link + Ecommerce foundation not started |

Executable now: create tenant → pick intent → open recommended hubs → operate each service’s existing CRUD.

## Part 4–6 — Home / Bundles / Accounting

| Item | Delivered this milestone |
| --- | --- |
| Business Type Wizard (home) | Yes — intent picker |
| Needs assessment + recommended services | Yes — `business-bundles.ts` |
| Bundle builder / subscription invoice auto-create | **Catalog only** — no new Accounting mutation without dedicated phase |
| Generated permissions/licenses | Uses existing onboarding + per-service entitlements; no new Core entitlement engine |

## Quality gates

- No new TODO/placeholder pages introduced
- Experience scaffolds reduced; remaining secondary resources either workspace-bound or readOnly
- Home is onboarding-first, not app-store-first
- Future phases explicitly not implemented